A CWLP Energy Expert answers customers' lighting questions
Search CWLP web site.
CWLP home page.
CWLP web site table of contents.
Management team bios; Organizational chart; Contact information; Community outreach programs; Employment opportunities.
Power generation; Transmission & distribution; Tree trimming/line clearance.
Water purification; Drinking water quality; Water distribution system; Outside-the-city water customers; Water conservation; Water rates; Sewer fees.
Lake water quality, including e.coli monitoring results; Lake water levels; Water sports; Lake parks and reservation information; Lake real estate/property leases.
How to sign up for, transfer or terminate service; Updating your account records; Reading meters; Senior Citizen Discount Rate; Bill payment options; Understanding your bill; Electric, water and sewer rates.
Energy efficiency information; Energy Rebates (heat pumps, water heaters, insulation); Energy efficiency FAQs; Energy audits and technical assistance; Water conservation.
Special services for our business customers; Economic Development Rider; Business Energy Update.
Current news and information about CWLP activities.
Link to City of Springfield web site.
Contact information for comments or questions concerning CWLP web site.

 

Ask the Energy Experts consists of some actual energy-related questions asked by real CWLP customers and the answers provided by our Energy Experts. Questions and answers are listed by general topic in the click-on options below. You might find some that provide you with advice you can use in your own home.

Page Divider Graphic

If you have a question you would like the Energy Experts to answer, you can email them at nrgxprts@cwlp.com, or contact the CWLP Energy Services Office.

Question and answer topics

Heat pumps vs. radiant heat 
Heat pump or air conditioner?
Replacing an old gravity furnace 
The economics of window replacement in uninsulated walls 
How cracks affect window efficiency 
Building energy efficiency into a new home 
Calculating the economic benefits of choosing high-efficiency 
The pros and cons of tankless water heaters 
Defining thermostat setback 
Does shutting off air supply to unused rooms save energy? 
Does siding increase a home's R-value? 
Insulating a brick wall 
Improving home lighting efficiency 
Using CFLs in three-way lamps 
Improving attic ventilation 
Calculating appliance energy use 
Replacing the whole air conditioner vs. just the A-coil 
The advantages of window film. 
Building passive solar features into a new home 

Heat Pumps vs. Radiant Heat

Question
I'm building a new home and considering installing either electric radiant heat panels or a heat pump. Which would you recommend?
   
Answer


An electric radiant heating system is a great way to achieve draft-free winter comfort. No blowing air means you can get by with a lower thermostat setting than you would with a forced-air heating system. That, and the radiant system's zonability — which lets you set different rooms at different temperatures — makes it less expensive to operate than a gas furnace and even, in some cases, a little less than a heat pump.

However, assuming you also want central air conditioning in your new home, the cost of installing whole-house radiant heat and a ducted cooling system will be much greater than that of an all-electric heat pump.

In certain situations, installing radiant panels can be appropriate - especially as a supplement to a central heating system in:

1.  a remote or add-on room to which you have trouble getting heat, or; 
2.  your most-used room(s), enabling you to turn down your central system's thermostat. 

 

 

Heat Pump or Air Conditioner?

Question
My gas furnace is less than ten years old, but my old central air conditioner will need to be replaced before the summer.  Would I be better off replacing it with a high-efficiency air conditioner or with an add-on heat pump?
Answer
The substantial rise in gas prices that has taken place over the past few years has made the add-on heat pump an economical option for home heating and cooling.

In the summer, the heat pump works just like an air conditioner to provide high-efficiency cooling.  In winter, it works in conjunction with the existing gas furnace to provide high-efficiency, low-cost heating.  During the majority of the heating season, the heat pump is all you'll need to keep your home comfortable.  During the coldest days—typically when the temperature drops below about 25-30 degrees Fahrenheit—the gas furnace will serve as your supplemental heat source. (In an all-electric heat pump system, supplemental heat would be provided by electric resistance coils, like those used in an electric furnace.)

Will an add-on heat pump continue to be more economical than a gas furnace-air conditioner combination? That depends, of course, on what happens with energy costs. Although we don't know for sure if gas prices will again reach the levels they did during Winter 2005/2006 (when Springfield customers were paying over $1.20 for each therm of gas), indications are that future winter gas prices are likely to remain well above $0.75 per therm. (In Winter 2006/2007, for example, the average price of gas has hovered between about $0.95 and $1 per therm.) Given that assumption, add-on heat pumps will continue to provide a more economical option than a gas furnace and air conditioner combination.

 

 

Replacing an Old Gravity Furnace

Question
I want to replace my old gravity furnace and window air conditioners with a more efficient heating and cooling system. Would a heat pump be a good option for me?
Answer
Given today's gas and electric prices, a heat pump will probably not only be a good option, it would be your best option. A high-efficiency heat pump could be installed as either an all- electric system or as an add-on to a new mid-efficiency (80%) gas furnace. Either way, it would provide you with lower-cost year-round comfort than either a gas furnace/air conditioner or electric resistance furnace/air conditioner combination. CWLP's booklet, Heat Pump: The All-Season Comfort System, has more information about heat pumps. CWLP electric customers can order their free copy online or by contacting the CWLP Energy Services Office.

 

The Economics of Window Replacement in Uninsulated Walls

 Question
Is it economically advisable to install new energy-efficient windows in uninsulated walls?
 Answer
Whether your walls are insulated or not, installing new windows for the sole purpose of increasing your home's energy efficiency would probably not be economically advisable. The monthly savings you would realize would, in most cases, be too small to provide a reasonable payback on your upfront investment.

If you're replacing your windows to improve your home's looks and comfort, by all means, choose high-efficiency multiple-pane models with low-E film or coating and an inert gas filling. Your energy savings should quickly off-set the cost difference between these and low- efficiency single-pane units.

But, if your goal is simply to increase efficiency, there are far more cost-effective things you can do — including installing storms over your existing windows, making sure the existing windows and frames are sufficiently caulked and weatherstripped, and insulating your walls. And remember, insulating your walls could qualify you for CWLP's Insulation Rebate.

CWLP's Home Efficiency Handbook contains more information about window efficiency. CWLP electric customers can order their free copy by contacting the Energy Services Office.

 

How Cracks Affect Window Efficiency

Question
Will a small crack in one pane of a double-pane window affect the window's efficiency?
Answer
If the window was filled with an inert gas (argon or krypton), the gas will seep through the crack, causing some loss in the window's overall efficiency. However, assuming the crack is very narrow and does not allow a significant amount of air infiltration, you'll still benefit from the insulating value provided by the dual panes and space of relatively "dead" air. So your actual energy-dollar loss typically will be small - probably no more than a couple of dollars per year. From an efficiency standpoint alone, the losses resulting from the crack would probably be too small to justify the cost of repairing or replacing the window.

 

 

Building Energy Efficiency Into a New Home

Question
How can we make sure the new home we plan to build will be energy efficient?
Answer


First and foremost, make sure you select a builder with a reputation for quality, energy- efficient construction. Insist on receiving detailed specifications outlining each efficiency feature to be included in the home. Among the features we strongly recommend are:

a passive solar design in which the house site and window positions maximize solar gain in winter and minimize it in summer. 
construction techniques that eliminate air and heat by-passes in walls and above the dropped ceilings often found in kitchens and baths. 
caulking at all structural joints to maximize air tightness. (Air wraps should not be used as a substitute for this.) 
- all-electric heat pumps with the highest cooling and heating efficiency levels you can afford to purchase.
properly located and well-sealed ductwork. (Ducts located in attics can waste tremendous amounts of energy.) 
high-quality insulation installation. You should consider "super-insulating" your walls and attics. 
high-efficiency, low-E windows. 
air-tight recessed light fixtures.

Regardless of which efficiency features you choose for your new home, the more involved you are in the construction process, the greater the likelihood you will be satisfied with the results once the project is completed.

 

 

Calculating the Economic Benefits of Choosing High-Efficiency

Question
My old furnace is on its last legs. Could I save enough on my monthly heating costs to justify the extra $350 cost of choosing a 97%-efficient gas furnace over an 80%-efficient one?
Answer


Before going further, there are two points you need to be aware of. First, your current system was probably 65% efficient when new. If it's in really bad shape, its efficiency is now probably no better than 50%. Second, although there is one furnace that can achieve up to 97%-efficiency under certain conditions, its maximum operating efficiency in most Springfield homes is 94%. So your real decision is whether to go from 50% to 80% or from 50% to 94%.

To calculate the energy-savings difference between two systems, divide the low efficiency by the high efficiency and subtract that figure from 1. In your case, the 80%-efficient furnace will reduce your current heating costs by 37% (1 - [.50/.80] = .37). The high-efficiency system will cut your costs by 47% (1 - [.50/.94] = .47).

Now, let's say your current heating costs average $750 a year. The 94%-efficient furnace would save you 10% ($75) more a year than the 80%-efficient model would. Dividing the $350 installation-price difference by the annual energy savings shows that you would achieve a payback on your efficiency investment in about 4.5 years. Since a well-maintained gas furnace can generally be expected to last 15-20 years, you should have many years of savings to spend or reinvest after you achieve payback. Of course, your actual savings and payback rate will depend on the actual purchase and installation price of the systems you consider.

 

 

The Pros and Cons of Tankless Water Heaters

Question
Should I replace my old water heater with one of those tankless heaters I've heard about?
Answer


The CWLP Energy Experts don't usually recommend a tankless system as a replacement for a centrally located traditional water heater. A gas unit, with its standing pilot light, probably will provide little or no savings over a well-insulated tank heater. An electric tankless system might be a little more efficient than a conventional water heater, but the savings most likely will be too small to offset the high purchase cost.

Tankless heaters are good for some specific point-of-use applications, such as when distance from a centralized tank heater makes it hard or inconvenient to get a sufficient supply of hot water to a kitchen or bathroom. In this case, you could install a tankless heater right in that room.

Otherwise, we recommend using a traditional tank heater and taking steps — like wrapping both the tank and water pipes with insulation and installing heat traps on the pipes where they exit the top of the tank B to ensure it will operate as efficiently as possible.

 

 

Defining Thermostat Setback

Question
What is thermostat setback?
Answer


Thermostat setback refers to the practice of setting your thermostat at higher- or lower-than- normal temperature so your air conditioner or furnace will run less during periods when you need less cooling or heating. The most appropriate times to set back your thermostat are at night and during the day when you expect to be away from the house for several hours.

Thermostat setback is an excellent way to cut your energy bills. For every degree you set your thermostat up in summer and down in winter, you can reduce your heating- and cooling-related energy use by about 2% or 3%— assuming the setback period lasts for several hours (such as overnight) each day. Setback is particularly easy if you use a programmable, electronic setback thermostat.

 

 

Does Shutting Off Air Supply to Unused Rooms Save Energy?

Question
I have two bedrooms that I seldom use. Can I save money on my energy bills by closing the heating and cooling vents in these rooms?
Answer


Under the right circumstances, shutting off heating and cooling to unused rooms might save you some money. But the savings typically will be small. If not done correctly, this procedure could actually increase your energy costs and seasonal discomfort.

Your savings will probably be greatest if the rooms you want to close off are near the air handler/furnace. Because of their proximity to the source of the conditioned air, these rooms would normally be warmest in winter and coolest in summer. By closing off the air supply to them, you can redirect more conditioned air to other areas of your home. This will let you improve comfort in the spaces you use most often without the need to increase energy use.

If your duct joints aren't well sealed, pressurization caused by shutting supply vents at the end of a duct run (in the room) can cause conditioned air to leak through the joints. Wrapping the joints in aluminum foil duct tape will help reduce this problem.

If you have duct dampers, you should use them instead of shutting room vents. Located inside the ducts, these devices can be closed to keep air from entering the ducts they control. This eliminates the potential for the duct pressurization problems mentioned earlier. If you have duct dampers, you will see a small metal tab on the duct about a foot from the main trunk. If the tab is lined up with the duct, the damper is open. To close the damper, turn the tab 90 degrees.

To avoid choking off too much air flow through your system, the rooms you close off should not represent over 20% of your home's total square footage. If you have a heat pump, we do not recommend closing off air supply to any part of your home.

 

 

Does Siding Increase a Home's R-Value?

Question
I plan to install vinyl siding on my house. Will this make my walls more energy efficient?
   
Answer


Siding alone will have almost no impact on the insulating capability (R-value) of your exterior walls. Even if the siding comes with a rigid board of insulation backing, this polystyrene beadboard is usually so thin and loose fitting that it will increase R-value only minimally.

If your walls have never been insulated, we strongly recommend you blow insulation directly into the wall cavities before installing your siding. This will bring your total wall R-value to about 13. The cost of doing this can vary from a few hundred to a few thousand dollars depending on who does the work.

To raise the R-value by an additional 5 points or so, you can sheath the walls with rigid board insulation before installing the siding.

 

 

Insulating a Brick Wall

Question
My brick wall has no wall insulation. How can I add some?
   
Answer


Insulating an existing brick wall poses problems not encountered when insulating walls covered with wood and other siding materials. In those types of structures, you would drill right into wall surface (either going directly through or lifting it and drilling into the sheathing below). With brick, however, you don't want to drill into the exterior surface and there's no way to lift the brick to expose the sheathing below.

If the walls are brick veneer over wood framing and you will be doing major indoor remodeling, you could remove the plaster or sheetrock from the interior surfaces of all your exterior walls and fill the exposed stud cavities with blanket insulation. Or you could drill through the interior wall surface and blow in loose-fill cellulose.  (You would need to patch the wall surface when done.)  If neither of these options would work for you, your only other real choice would involve blowing insulation into the wall cavity through holes drilled into the stud wall's top and sole plates. To do this, you will work in the attic and basement or crawl space rather than outside, as you would normally do when blowing in wall insulation.

If your walls are solid brick, if access to wall plates is blocked by a shallow roof or slab foundation, or if the cost of installing the insulation is higher than you want to pay, you can take other steps to reduce energy costs and discomfort. These include moving beds and chairs away from exterior walls, sealing air infiltration points, and using shades or drapes to cut heat loss through windows.

 

 

Improving Home Lighting Efficiency

Question
I'd like to replace the 150-watt bulb in my reading lamp with a more energy-efficient bulb but I don't want to reduce the light output. What are my options?
   
Answer


You can improve your home's lighting efficiency by replacing incandescent bulbs with either halogens or compact fluorescent lamps (CFLs).

Screw-in halogen bulbs use up to 17% less energy than, last up to three times longer than, and are similar in size and shape to standard incandescent "A" bulbs. But they have light output equivalencies only up to 100 watts.

For your reading lamp and in many other applications, you will be better off replacing your incandescent bulbs with CFLs. They use 70% to 75% less energy and last 10 to 13 times longer than incandescents. They are available in wattage equivalencies ranging from 25 to 150 watts. You'll need a 39-watt CFL to replace the incandescent bulb now in your reading lamp.

 

 

Using CFLs in Three-Way Lamps

Question
Can I use a compact fluorescent lamp in my three-way lamp?
   
Answer


Yes. You could use either a standard (one-way) or a three-way CFL. Each would provide a different effect.

The standard CFL works in a three-way lamp exactly the same way a one-way incandescent does - the light remains off for three of every four clicks of the lamp's switch and you get only one level of light. Just like a three-way incandescent, a three-way CFL would provide you with three different lights levels that would be equivalent to the light output of a 50/100/150-watt incandescent.

 

 

Improving Attic Ventilation

Question
At what temperature should I set the thermostat of my temperature-controlled attic fan?
   
Answer


A thermostat setting of 110°F should be adequate to guard against excessive attic heat buildup while ensuring the fan doesn't run more than absolutely necessary.

Heat buildup in an attic (especially one that is under-insulated) can contribute greatly to a home's summer cooling load. Ventilation systems, like your temperature-controlled fan, reduce the amount of buildup, thus lowering cooling costs and improving comfort. However, because your power vent uses electricity, its energy will cut into your overall savings.

A more efficient way to ventilate your attic would be to install a well-designed passive system that uses no electricity at all. A good passive system could include soffit vents, installed every 8' to 12' along the roof eaves, and a continuous ridge vent. This "low-to-high" venting arrangement would allow a cooling draft of air to be pulled continuously through the attic.

Whatever venting method you use to control attic heat buildup, remember that the best way to limit heat transfer from the attic to your living space is to have adequate insulation in the attic.  We recommend a minimum attic insulation level of R-30.  R-38 is preferred.

 

 

Calculating Appliance Energy Use

Question
How can I calculate the cost of energy used by my electric appliances?
   
Answer


For "simple" appliances - like light bulbs, irons, hair dryers, TVs and radios - you can multiply the device's wattage rating (amps x volts) by the number of hours you use it each month. Divide your answer by 1000. That tells you how many kilowatt-hours (kWh) of electricity the appliance uses per month. Finally, multiply the kWh by your electric cost (which, on an annual basis, averages about 9.5¢ per kWh for the majority of CWLP's residential customers). (Cost estimates last updated September 30, 2008)

This calculation method doesn't work well for more complex systems - especially air conditioners, refrigerators, water heaters and others that cycle on and off during operation. For help estimating the energy use of these types of appliances, you can contact the Energy Services Office.

More information about calculating appliance energy usage, including a chart listing the approximate energy use of many common household appliances, can be found on our Appliance Energy Use page.

 

 

Replacing the Whole Air Conditioner vs. Just the A-Coil

Question
My 15-year-old air conditioner, which was high-efficiency when I bought it, worked well until the A-coil recently started leaking. Should I replace the entire system or can I get away with replacing just the A-coil?
   
Answer


We recommend replacing the entire system. Your condensing unit is nearing the end of its expected lifespan and could begin experiencing serious problems at any time, especially if the new A-coil you install is not properly matched to the old condenser. By replacing both units at once, you will reduce the likelihood of component mismatching that can lead to compressor failure.

Replacing the entire system will also lower your cooling costs. Fifteen years ago, even the highest efficiency air conditioners had SEERS of only about 10. Today, SEERs of 14 or more are common. (In fact, federal standards require heat pumps and central air conditioners manufactured after January 23, 2006, to have minimum SEERs of 13.) Going from a SEER 10 to a SEER 14 will reduce your cooling costs by 40%!

Another consideration might be to replace the old air conditioner with a heat pump (either all-electric or as an add-on to a gas furnace).  This would allow you to reduce both your cooling and heating costs, and could qualify you for CWLP's Heat Pump Rebate.

 

 

The Advantages of Window Film

Question
Will I save a lot of energy if I cover my west-facing sliding glass doors with window film?
   
Answer

Sunlight shining in your home can cause a tremendous amount of internal summer heat gain. Applying a light-reflecting film to west and east-facing windows that receive a lot of sunlight can cut your cooling costs. Actual savings will depend on the VLT (visible light transmittance) rating of the film you use. The lower the VLT, the less light the film will allow to enter your house and the greater your savings will be.

You'll save year-round and improve winter comfort if you use a light-reflecting film with  low-E capabilities. This type of film reflects both light and infrared energy back toward its source, thus helping prevent furnace and body heat from radiating out through your windows in winter.

 

 

Building Passive Solar Features into a New Home

Question
I am planning to build a new house.  How can I make use of passive solar energy?
   
Answer

The first thing you should do is to try to purchase a lot that will allow you to orient your home so one of the two longest walls faces due south.  Then design the house so that the majority of your windows are on this wall, with large roof overhangs shielding them from as much summer sun as possible.  This will allow your home to benefit from a maximum amount of solar gain in winter, when you need it, while limiting solar gain in summer, when you don't need it.  Second, because windows are a very common source of cold air infiltration in winter, limiting the number and size of windows on both the west and north sides will also help enhance comfort and efficiency when the cold winter winds blow.

Don't forget, when designing your passive solar home, to make sure it is well insulated.  A well-insulated building will help block the sun's heat from entering the home in summer and will help keep solar gain inside the home in the winter.

Last updated: 09/30/08